Text of the novel

  • Front page
  • The world of "Truth and Justice"
  • About us
  • Est
  • Rus
  • Eng
  • Front page
  • The world of "Truth and Justice"
  • About us
  • Est
  • Rus
  • Eng

The world of "Truth and Justice"

The world of "Truth and Justice"

Who am I and how did I become myself? With whom do I belong? These are complicated questions, simultaneously both contemporarily relevant, as well as eternally pondered. It is no wonder, then, that the nearly century old story of Vargamäe and its inhabitants still offers a solid basis on which to approach the topic of identity, even today.

By clicking on the objects found in the picture, you can investigate how personal identity develops through interaction with other people, or the role of objects, skills, and landscapes in the development of cultural identity, and also how our relation to other living species has changed since the time of Vargamäe.

Contents

Me and nature
  1. Landscape
  2. Animals

     

Me and material culture
  1. Oldest Object
  2. Skills

     

Me and others
  1. Relations
  2. Values
  3. Social Structure
Me and text
  1. Text
  2. Film language

     

Film Language

How does the film "Truth and Justice" connect the Estonian national culture with the global context?

Movie trailer

In his movie, Tanel Toom retells A. H. Tammsaare’s story about life in Vargamäe using Hollywood film language. This combination of distant cultural contexts addresses the contemporary Estonian audience on different levels. On the one hand, the novel Truth and Justice understood as one of the most canonical representations of the Estonian national character, a work deeply rooted in the local context. On the other hand, the format chosen to tell the story by the director successfully merges it with global culture.

In present day culture these kinds of hybrid forms reflect an important tendency in modern identity formation. Most people in the world now develop a bicultural identity where part of their identity is rooted in their local culture, and another part is adapted to the global situation. Or they may develop a hybrid identity, successfully combining elements of global and local situations in a mix. (Arnett 2002, Hermans and Dimaggio 2007).

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II

Part 1

The simultaneity of both universalizing and particularizing tendencies in culture is named glocalization (globalization + localization). Familiarize yourself with the following examples of glocalization taken from Estonian culture.

Sushi the Estonian way
Trad.Attack!
Muhu keds
  • What other examples of glocalization do you know?
  • Can glocalization pose a threat to the authenticity of smaller cultures, or can it on the contrary help to preserve them?
  • Is the phenomenon of glocalization inherent exclusively to the 21st century or can we find similar tendencies also in previous times?

Part 2

Watch the trailer of Truth and Justice. What aspects in this video are inherent to Hollywood cinema in your opinion?

Hollywood has influenced the movie industry all around the world and can be considered a universal language of film that is shared and understood by the majority of people. But what are the universal characteristics of Hollywood cinema?

  1. Pick a Hollywood movie genre, watch a Youtube video about it, and bring out what the most important elements of that genre.
    • Comedy 
    • War movies
    • Science Fiction
    • Crime
    • Western
  2. Choose one short scene from the book.
  3. Create a script and a storyboard for this scene.
  4. Answer the questions or complete the following tasks:
    • Compare the original scene from the book with the version you made according to the elements of a specific movie genre.
    • Bring out what changed in the characters; in the mood and atmosphere of the scene; and in the overall meaning of the text.
    • Compare your work with other classmates. Are there any aspects that are universal for all different genres?

Text

How do we understand artistic texts and ourselves through them?

Frame from the movie

“It would be wonderful, if children could learn biblical history together with histories from the eposes as “Kalevala” or “Kalevipoeg”; they would learn to see the biblical history of the world creation as they see any epic history of the world creation. [...] Let’s teach them how to observe and compare. Let they read the Bible together with “Kalevioeg”, “Kalevala” and with corresponding Greek and Roman texts. [...] Let’s teach them to see the infinity of nature, worlds and universes, let's teach them to notice our mind that searches for completeness [...] It would be wonderful through the example of Biblical stories to show children, how many mistakes are in great books“.

A. H. Tammsaare (1988)

Communication with a text is a complicated process. The understanding of a text is based on the analysis of its inner structure, its historical context, and its relations to other texts. However, reading cannot be equated to a simple decoding, as many texts do not only transmit information from an author to a receiver, but also invite a reader to respond, listen to him- or herself, and to be creative.

Thus, in Truth and Justice the Bible plays a significant role, and connections to the Holy Scripture are recognizable on different levels of Tammsaare’s work. While reading the novel, considering biblical motifs may help us to reach a deeper meaning of the text and understand better its poetics and its author’s ideas. From the other side, we may also read Truth and Justice or watch its adaptation more subjectively, connecting the text to contemporary cultural contexts or personal experiences. Both types of reading may turn out to be enthralling.

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II

Part 1

Job, Léon Bonnat, 1880
Christ in The Desert, I. Kramskoi, 1872

In the novel Truth and Justice the Bible is primarily Andres’s daily reading. It serves for this character as the source of his understanding of justice, as the support in his moments of doubt, and as his consolation. However, over the course of the novel Andres’s reading of the Bible becomes self-serving and the text raises even more doubts in the soul of the Eespere’s master: “How could justice, as he read it in the Bible, help him if he couldn’t put it to use in his own life? Of what value was God’s word if God didn’t keep His promises at Vargamäe?“ (p. 508).

Secondly, there are two stories from the Bible that become crucial for the poetics of the novel – these are Suffering of Job from the Old Testament and Temptation of Christ from the New Testiment. In Tammsaare’s text, Andres does not only read about Job, but turns into Job: “…he opened the cabinet, took out the Bible, sat down at the table, and started reading the story of Job. It was through the words of Job that he wanted to talk to his Lord.” (p. 643). Connections between Pearu’s destiny and the story of Christ’s temptations are not so explicit, but hints pertaining to this biblical story are recognizable in different replicas of Pearu’s, and in the following comparison made by Indrek: “the Christ figure that reminded him of Pearu’s white shirt“ (p. 559).

Thirdly, the Bible is made incarnate through nature, and it is the text with which the peasants fight for survival:

“Vargamäe speaks through its actions. In a couple of years it will sprout a thousand willow bushes to block your scythe—that’s its Lord’s Prayer. It raises stones in front of your plow like a pack of wolves—those are its Ten Commandments. In a few years it will fill the ditches you only just dug, and that’s its lesson and verse. In a couple of dozen years it will cripple your arms and legs and send you off to the cemetery, and that’s its Bible story. This is the way Vargamäe speaks, and it’s the way Vihukse spoke. It’s no different at Hundipalu, Ämmasoo, Rava, Kukessaare, Aaseme, Võlla, Kassiaru, or any other place where people learn their prayers.” (p. 525)

The biblical motifs that are recognizable on the different levels of the novel turn Truth and Justice into mythical, universal, and repeatable story. In this sense, the novel is similar to the works of Fyodor Dostoevsky, whose oeuvres Tammsaare highly appreciated, and even translated into the Estonian language (for example, Crime and Punishment).

Task

infographics eng

Using the keywords from the infographics, find more quotations with references to the Bible and answer the following questions.

  • In what contexts are these words used?
  • How often do they make connections to biblical stories?
  • What role does the Bible play in the world of Vargamäe?
  • What other references to biblical stories you may find in the text? Are there characters who remind you of Adam and Eve, or Cain and Abel?
  • How do biblical motifs change your understanding of the novel?

Part 2

People often turn to books (or songs or movies) in search of answers to the questions related to their own lives. Whether it is a novel, a poem, a self-help book, or a religious text, all of these can be used by readers to make sense of their individual experiences. Andres from Vargamäe has his own interpretation of the Bible that is deeply connected to his personality and comes from his private beliefs and values. Would Pearu read the Bible in the same way as Andres does?

Think about all the times that an artistic text served as a catalyst for revisiting your own experiences and thoughts. Could you name at least one text that strongly affected your personality and identity? Is it possible to use Truth and Justice to try and understand yourself?

Task

  1. At first, fill in the table with the episodes from the film that resonated with you most of all and caused the strongest feelings and emotions. Then fill the second part of the table with the main general topic that in your opinion every episode represents (there might be different variants).
The episodes from the filmThe topics that the episodes represent
1
2
3
4
5
cloud_downloadrefreshSave as PDF
  1. Compare your table to the tables of your classmates. How different are they? Why so?
  2. Choose one episode and topic from the scheme for a deeper analysis. Think about your own experience.
    • Do you have a personal connection to the chosen topic? There is no need to speak about it, if you do not want to.
    • Is there a conflict in the episode? Is there a potential conflict in the topic?
    • Do you like how the conflict is solved in the film?
    • Are there characters with whom you can identify?
    • Are there characters who cause negative emotions in you?
    • Do you evaluate characters’ decisions from the point of view of contemporaneity, or from the point of view of the time that the film tells us about?
    • With whom are you in dialogue? With characters themselves or with the authors -- that is, with A. Tammsaare, and/or Tanel Toom?
    • Has the chosen episode changed something in your understanding of the topic that it represents?

Social Structure

What is the structure of society and where do we belong in it?

In the 19th century, social hierarchies were extremely important, and everything from gender, age, marital status, class, profession, and so on, could play a role. Men had last word in everything; sons were more wanted than daughters; the young had to obey the elders. Social borders were not easy to transcend and people did not have much to choose from. Yet, even some characters of Truth and Justice challenged their prescribed identities and strove for something else. How has the situation changed throughout history?

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II
  • Part III

Part 1

Social hierarchy - who is subordinate to whom? Try to find the social place of different people in the world of Truth and Justice. 

god
emperor
landowner
farmer
priest
farmer’s wife
farmer’s father
boys
judge
pub owner
girls
farm servants
shepard boys
travelling merchant
beggar
important — the most important
cloud_download Download the chart
Start again
  • Which factors influenced the place of a person in the social hierarchy? What is the value of wealth, sex, age, class? Can a hierarchy change depending on the situation?
  • Can you remember situations from Truth and Justice in which the difference of the social status of the characters was important?
  • What can we say about contemporary social structure? How would you visualize it – as a pyramid, circle, something else?
  • How do you see the ideal society of the future? Which factors would play a role?

Part 2

What are women and men made of? Think about the gender stereotypes found in 19th century Vargamäe and drag the corresponding items to the figures.

prejudice
prejudice
prejudice
force
force
force
lust
lust
lust
beauty
beauty
beauty
obedience
obedience
obedience
labour
labour
labour
humour
humour
humour
friendship
friendship
friendship
gossip
gossip
gossip
strategy
strategy
strategy
competition
competition
competition
collaboration
collaboration
collaboration
protection
protection
protection
nurturing
nurturing
nurturing
logic
logic
logic
intuition
intuition
intuition
truth
truth
truth
justice
justice
justice
sympathy
sympathy
sympathy
tenderness
tenderness
tenderness
rationality
rationality
rationality
sensibility
sensibility
sensibility
Man
important — the most important
Woman
important — the most important
cloud_download Download the chart
Start again
  • What were the roles of men and women in a 19th century Estonian village? Try to find quotes and examples from Truth and Justice. What is an ideal man or ideal woman, in this scenario? How were real men and women perceived?
  • "What Are Little Boys Made Of" is a popular nursery rhyme from the beginning of the 19th century. Do you know any contemporary texts reflecting the same topic? Watch this advertising campaign from Nike: What does this advertisement express? Do you agree with its message?
  • What are you made of? Think of the most important things in your life and make a drawing. Has this drawing anything to do with (your) gender?

Part 3

Each one of us has multiple identities, which is affected by the perspectives and expectations of our parents, friends, colleagues, and ourselves. Use the meme "How I see myself" to analyze the identity of Vargamäe's children: Andres, Indrek, Joosep, and Liisi. 

Divide into groups and select a character. Fill in the table with visuals: you can find photographs on the Internet, upload photographs of your drawings, or make a pantomime and take photographs of yourselves.

Drag & drop or upload an image here!

Upload an image here!

How my parents see me (expectations)

Drag & drop or upload an image here!

Upload an image here!

How society sees me (social status)

Drag & drop or upload an image here!

Upload an image here!

How I see myself (ideal self)

Drag & drop or upload an image here!

Upload an image here!

How I really am (real self)
cloud_downloadrefreshSave as PDF
  • What does the perspective depend on? Why can each and every person be seen so diversely? How does this “disintegration” affect us?
  • Try to find exact quotes dealing with the image of different characters. For instance, his parents see Indrek as a smart guy that could make it into higher society, while Pearu considers him a “horse-stealer”.
  • Make the same meme about yourself. Compare your meme with your group members and discuss, what aspects of your life seem the most important when viewed from different perspectives.
  • Watch the video and discuss the reasons behind such misunderstanding.

Value Conflicts

Why do different values cause conflicts between people?

Scene from the movie: Andres and Pearu

import_contactsSame place in the novel (pgs 114-115)

What we consider valuable in life is connected to the value system of the society in which we live.  However, the way we understand different values or the importance we assign to them can vary greatly depending on each individual person. For example, we can assume that many people would consider both freedom and security as important values of our society. But if we were to  begin a discussion about which of these two is more significant, or how to even define what “freedom” and “security” mean, reaching a consensus would appear to be a very difficult task.

Disputes about values can lead to conflicts not only between neighbours but also between entire social groups. Humans are willing to fight relentlessly for having their understanding of values acknowledged as “truthful” or “correct.” Value systems serve as compasses to help us navigate our way in life. And it is natural that all of us need to feel assurance in a frightening and chaotic world, to feel that we are moving in the right direction. No wonder, then, that the landlords of Vargamäe were so stubborn in their quarrels about truth and justice.

vaartused

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II

Part 1

The value systems of Andres and Pearu (work in pairs)

  1. Divide roles in such a manner that one person represents the perspective of Andres, and the other person the perspective of Pearu.
  2. Explain to each other, from the perspective of your character, what the following words mean to you: Money, Work, Love, Justice, Truth, Leisure, Faith, Deception, Strength. Bring examples from the novel and the film to justify your standpoint.
  3. Represent the value system of your character in a pyramid. Pick six values out from those mentioned above, and place them in the pyramid according to what your character values most being placed at the top of the pyramid.
  4. Compare the pyramids of Andres and Pearu. Are there any overlaps in the value systems of the Vargamäe landlords? Imagine that Pearu and Andres would have to agree on a shared value system and build a joint pyramid. Which values would they agree upon? Which values would cause a conflict? What do you think they would manage to come up with as a compromise?
truth
truth
truth
justice
justice
justice
love
love
love
work
work
work
money
money
money
rest
rest
rest
faith
faith
faith
cunning
cunning
cunning
force
force
force
Andres
important — the most important
Pearu
important — the most important
cloud_download Download the chart
Start again

Part 2

Our own value systems (work in groups of four to six people)

Pearu and Andres’s quarrels may often seem silly, but how well can we ourselves compromise when it comes to our own personal worldview?

  1. Acquaint yourself with the values below.
  2. One by one, begin to add values to the pyramid, so that every person gets to add a value, up until the pyramid has ten values in total. Before applying it to the pyramid, the chooser of the value must explain to the rest of the group what this value means to them personally. For now, it is not important to pay attention to the position of the values within the pyramid.
  3. Once ten values have been chosen, re-position them in the pyramid so that the most important value would be found at the the tip of the pyramid. Try to find a combination that all group members accept, or would be willing to accept.
Honesty
Freedom
Healthy lifestyle
Love
Diligence
Pleasure
Family
Multiculturalism
Peace
Environmental sustainability
Fairness
Wealth
Scientific approach
Self-realization
Nationalism
Spirituality
Traditions
Education
Equality
Security
important — the most important
cloud_download Download the chart
Start again
  1. Discuss together:
    • How many people in the group are satisfied with the value system you have built? Are there any people who feel that this pyramid contradicts their worldview to a great extent?
    • What were the values that were the most disputed?
    • Were there any values that held different meanings for different group members? What do you think is the reason behind those differences?
    • How did you reach compromises? Did all the members of your group have an equal influence in compiling the pyramid? If not, then what was the reason behind this (passivity, persuasiveness, difference in temperaments, etc.)?

For the idea of building a pyramid of values we would like to thank Mari-Liis Nummert and the University of Tartu Centre of Ethics. Check out other value-related games developed by the Centre of Ethics here.

Additional material: Exhibition "Me and Truth and Justice"

Understanding and Misunderstanding

How do we interpret other people’s messages?

Scene from the movie: Mari and Juss

import_contactsSame place in the novel (pgs 146-147)

Communication between people is a complicated process. We appeal to each other not only through words, but also through gestures, intonation, and facial expressions. Look at the row of pictures, what aspects can help you understand your interlocutor?

pose
expression
crylaugh
distance
gestures

On the one hand there are many features of communication such as tone, sight, laughter, or tears that help us understand each other. Whereas, on the other hand, there is no surprise that with the variety of possibilities we sometimes misunderstand each other. For instance, the behaviour of an interlocutor may be very misleading: sometimes it happens that people express what they do not mean to express, or do not know what it is that they even want to express.

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II

Part 1

Analysis of the relationship between Juss and Mari

  1. Read the excerpt from the novel. What channels do Mari and Juss use for communication?
  2. What do they notice in each others’ behaviour and what stays unnoticed?
  3. What is the reason for miscommunication between the characters? Why does Mari tease Juss and how does he interpret it?
  4. How does Mari's behaviour affect Juss’s identity and self-determination?
  5. Compare the excerpt from the novel to the excerpt from the adaptation. Is the communicative act presented in the film in a similar way? What are the differences?
  6. Watch the video and think about real-life situations wherein we make comments about each others’ appearances. Is it always easy to evaluate the impact of our words?

Part 2

Roleplay

Do you remember the famous game Charades wherein people try to explain something without words? In order to understand the value of different channels of communication, play a small role-playing game.

Choose a partner and play the same dialogue over several times. Try to change the meaning of the dialogue during each turn.

      A: I am moving to Tokyo.
      B: I am very happy about that.

At first, try to say it without any intonation, gestures, or mimicry. Is it easy? Afterwards, both partners should attempt to express various different emotions without naming them beforehand: happiness, sadness, confusion, anger, indifference. Think about how you express your emotions. Also, are your interpretations of your partner’s emotions always correct?

The Oldest Thing

What things do people store in their houses and pass from generation to generation?

Frame from the movie

Krõõt made no reply because her husband was right, but the rain held off long enough, allowing them to keep the rye dry, and she started feeling sorry for herself. Why did Andres get angry before he knew what would happen with the rain? And why was he so sharp? Didn’t he realize that she, Krõõt, was carrying their first child in her womb?

When they got back to the house, she went to the barn and wept bitterly, leaning against her large, white, wooden chest. Andres came looking for her, and when he saw her crying, he remained silent. Then he stepped closer, though he didn’t touch her.

“Krõõt, don’t cry. I was afraid the rain would soak us and the rye too, or I wouldn’t have...”

So they made up, but their first conflict was followed by others, and now, when Krõõt cried, Andres no longer came to comfort her. And Krõõt no longer went to cry against her mother’s wooden chest, as she had the first time she needed compassion and tenderness. Besides the chest, she had the old cow, Maasik, and the mare, which were her dowry, but in her sorrow, she didn’t go to them either, unless perhaps she started to cry while milking.

In the third quarter of the 19th century, most objects in rural households were handmade, as opposed to bought. Regardless, people possessed at least a few things with symbolic value, that had been cherished and passed down from generation to generation. These are things that could have been created for special occasions, such as weddings, or rare objects brought from elsewhere. For example, the most valuable thing for Krõõt, one of the main characters of the novel, was the white chest that she brought from her parents’ house. It is interesting that these valuable and rare things often become museum exhibits. People used to take care of their inheritances and stored them with more care, in comparison with those daily household items that were used often. It is thus more likely for us to see a holiday dress in some museum exhibition, and not an everyday one.

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.

Part 1

  1. Take a photo of the oldest object in your household, or the object that is the most valuable for your family. If the object is small, try to find a place with good lighting and a plain background, so that the object is visible.
  2. Tell the story of this object. To find the answers, you may need to ask your relatives or search for information on the Internet.
    • What thing is it? What is its function?
    • How did it appear in your home?
    • Why has it been important for your family to keep it?
    • Does it mean anything to you personally?
    • Are you going to pass it down to future generations?
  3. Share your story and the photo on Pildiait – a visual database of the Estonian National Museum. You can also publish your stories on social media with the hashtag #koigevanemasi or share them on Relikva, an online platform for creating personal museums.
  4. Prepare a short presentation of your object and talk about it in class.
  5. Look at your classmates’ works and discuss this question in class: What can these stories tell us about the authors of both the objects and the stories?

Landscape

Which eras have left footprints onto your home landscapes?

When hearing the word “landscape” we usually imagine an area with distinctive characteristics. Landscape can be either prairie or forest, sea or deserted, urban or never touched by human. People change landscapes by turning deserts into cities, swamps into fields and arable lands, like people from Vargamäe did. Landscape, such as our home area that plays a crucial role in our identity. We can also find footprints of different times in landscapes - ditches and hills, ruins of buildings, fields and plants, fossils, roads and pathways, but also objects related to legends and personal memories. Landscape reminds of a palimpsest or of walls of an old building that was repaired for several times where some layers of letters or paint have been peeled off, revealing older layers. The better we know a landscape, the better literate we are in reading such footprints.

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II
  • Part III

Part 1

Browse your family album and choose a photograph of your home landscape that's at least as old as you are. Take a photo or find a photo on the Internet of the exact same location nowadays. If you don’t have a suitable picture, you can choose the initial photograph from Ajapaik or another digital archive (e.g. ERR, Fotis, Kivike, Vanadpildid, Digar)

  • Describe the differences of the two, what has been added, lost, changed?
  • What are the oldest and newest objects visible and when do these date from?
  • Do you think that the landscape you grew up in influenced your identity?
The place in the past
The place nowadays

Drag and drop or upload an old photo!

Upload an old photo!

Drag and drop or upload a photo from nowadays!

Upload a photo from nowadays!



Photo description

Click on the text to change it:
Write here about the depicted place and the origin of the old photo.

Comments on pictures

Click on the object to comment on it. Comments will appear here:

When you're ready, download your work as a PDF and email it to your teacher.

cloud_downloadrefreshSave as PDF

Part 2

What is the role of landscape in Truth and Justice, both the book and the film? How does the manner in which the landscape is represented in the book, and the way in which the landscape is represented in the film, differ from one another? 

Truth and Justice can be seen as a book that describes the relationship of Estonians to the land, or with natural surroundings in a wider sense. Conversely, the novel and film have come to influence how Estonians think about their landscapes and nature in general. 

Semiotician Timo Maran has developed the model of the “nature-text” to describe the interrelationship between written texts and nature.  

The concept of the “nature-text” refers to the meaningful connectedness between nature and certain texts – one is not understandable without knowing the other. For example, it is difficult to understand the main storylines and topics in Truth and Justice when one has never visited a bog, and does not know what it feels like to move around in one. In dragging the stuck cow out from the bog, Andres and Pearu bicker on the topics of digging ditches and struggling with rocky and fruitless land, and also express their joy on growing and harvesting grain — these topics would not be entirely understandable for the reader who cannot imagine the difficulty of living in a boggy landscape.

Conversely, human activity and culture creates new signs pertaining to everyday landscapes, for example in the form of place names. The original “Robber’s Rise” is located in the Kõrvemaa region, and locals from Kõrvemaa know some of the places from the book well. For example, the location of the big stone where the kids are playing while participating in the herd is well known, with locals calling this stone “Mängukivi” ( or “Playstone”, a stone that is meant for playing). Similarly known by the locals is the road up to “Robber`s Rise”, including its bog bridge. This bridge was described in Truth and Justice as a place where carriages and horses were constantly stuck.


Moreover, the new “Robber`s Rise“ that was built for the film will also remain — situated near the village of Vastse-Roosa, where filming occurred, this new construction has become an important place in and of itself, becoming well known and prominently advertised as a filming location.

Task

In order to understand how nature or landscapes is/are represented, interpreted and described in a literary text, one should examine how the author has constructed his descriptions. In other words, one should pay attention to the natural signs (i.e. signs derived from nature) found in the written text.

  1. Find a paragraph in the Truth and Justice novel that describes the landscape. (You can use the search function and insert some keywords indicating nature/landscape, farming, digging ditches, bad roads, etc.)
  2. Based on the paragraph you find, answer to following questions:
    • From whose perspective is the landscape described? Does the author refer to bodily feelings or activities that are related to the landscape?
    • Are there some specific species names, place names or natural terms (for example to describe surface forms) used by the author?
    • Is it possible to find evaluations, assessments, or emotional messaging related to landscapes/nature in the given text? If yes, what kind?

Part 3

The landscape as such, more specifically the bog, can be seen as one of the characters of Truth and Justice. Over the course of the past fifty years, however, opinions and practices regarding the mires have changed tremendously for Estonians. The novel Truth and Justice represents a common idea found in traditional farming, wherein mires are seen as useless landscapes that need to be drained before they are valuable or useful.

In truth, when buying the Vargamäe farm, Andres hadn’t given much thought to its existing worth. Instead, he envisioned what he could do with the land, how much value he could add to it. That’s why the young master, during the day’s tour, thought only about his ideas and plans, imagining what the land or the scraggly little birches, pines, and spruces might look like if they dug ditches here and there, of this or that length. Would the tops of the birches straighten out in a few years? Would spruce and pine show new life and shoot up, as if stung by a wasp?

(Tammsaare 2014: 30)

From the 1970s onward, the ecological value of mires became more clear in the public domain, mainly because of the actions and speeches of scientists and nature protection activists.

Nowadays, these mires are loved and valued landscapes — boardwalks made for mires are very popular for visitors, for example. These mires have also been the object of several projects intended to restore them. In 2018, Estonia’s leading newspaper Postimees organized a poll inquiring about the symbols of Estonia, and the bog was elected to be the most “Estonian“ thing by those who responded. Mires are now commonly described as beautiful, scenic, peaceful, and invigorating landscapes. 

Changes in values and understanding regarding mires are well highlighted when comparing the landscape presented in the Truth and Justice novel (originally published from 1926-1933) to the one presented in the film (2019). In the book, there are many struggles related to digging ditches on dry land and picking rocks from the field. In the film, the landscape is represented with beautiful drone shots of foggy and scenic mires, as we are used to seeing on tourism sites and in advertisements:

Task

  1. Find a story, song, phrase, or poem from a period earlier than the 1970s, wherein mires are described or mentioned. For help finding some Estonian texts, you can use the database „Mires in Estonian culture“ created by the Estonian Fund for Nature. Another useful source is the Estonian place-lore database KOOBAS created by the Estonian Folklore Archives (you can select teated from the menu and use soo i.e. “mire” or raba i.e. “bog” as keywords to search texts). For English texts, try Google or the options described in the following paragraph.
  2. For the next step, please find one text, video, story, article, or song from either nowadays or from a few decades past. Youtube may be helpful for finding videos, and for texts/articles you may use the database of Estonian articles „ISE“.
Example from the pastExample from nowadays
1
cloud_downloadrefreshSave as PDF
  1. Share and describe the stories or videos that you found with one another and provide answers to the following questions:
    • How are mires represented in these writings/videos and what is the main issue or idea regarding mires – are there dominant scientific descriptions, visual aspects, emotional aspects or assessments, etc., in the text/video?
    • Are there any differences between earlier and contemporary texts/videos? If yes, what are the differences?
    • How are the mires represented in your culture?

Valuable Skills

What skills and resources were important for farming in the 19th century?

Scene from the movie: working

import_contactsSame place in the novel (page 91)

To survive in the harsh environment of a 19th-century village, people needed to be able to do a lot of things. They needed to know how to build houses, cultivate crops, breed cattle, dewater bogs, and make things from scratch with their own hands. Skills played a crucial role in understanding the place of a person in the social hierarchy. For instance, even a poor person like Andres from Vargamäe could gain respect and love for being strong and hardworking, or a farmhand such as Jaagup for playing the harmonica, or an individual such as Hundipalu Tiit for being fluent and literate in German.

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.

Part 1

Students should divide into four groups and create their own farms. The goal is to make the most sustainable and successful farm.

Turn the raffle wheel
Matsalu
Lahemaa
Vilsandi
Soomaa

1. Analyze the resources

Imagine that you have received a plot of land and need to build a farm from scratch. Carefully analyze your landscape and compile a short overview of your resources. What type of landscape is it? Is it plain or hilly? Does it have bodies of water, such as lakes, rivers, bogs or sea channels? What kind of vegetation does it have? What do you know about its weather and climate? Where is it possible to place fields and buildings?

Land options

Did you know that people used to live on the territory of the contemporary national parks in Estonia? Since the landscape conditions in these areas can remain the same over the course of centuries, it is possible to see what the life was like in the past. Parks are situated in different parts of Estonia and have their own distinctive features. On the website dedicated to the protected areas you can find detailed maps, photographs, and information about the natural conditions.

  • Lahemaa
  • Soomaa
  • Matsalu
  • Vilsandi

2. Make your plan

Think about how you are going to use your resources. What agricultural works will take place at your farm? Imagine that there are 8-10 workers on a farm. Choose at least one skill for each worker. Keep in mind various areas: cattle breeding, field work, woodworking, housework, construction, logging, crafts. Are any skills not related to work important to you? (Such as singing, dancing, fighting, etc.).

3. Strategize

What kinds of goods can you produce on your farm? What are you going to be famous for amongst your neighbours? Make a list of the top-5 goods you can produce on your farm with the resources you have. Present your farm to other groups (use the information from previous stages of the game).

4. Choose a partner

Evaluate the other groups’ presentations and decide which other farm you would like to be partners or neighbours with. Each group has to choose one farm and explain their choice.

5. Choose the winner

Count the voices and choose the most popular farm amongst the neighbours. Discuss and decide which resources and skills turned out to be the most valuable. Discuss, what forms people’s identity and what influences their position in contemporary society.

Animals

What kind of relationships do the characters of “Truth and Justice” have with other animals? How have the attitudes towards and relations with other animals changed since then?

Photo by Renee Altrov

“Good heavens,” she exclaimed. “Why on earth did you drive her into the marsh if the ground is so soft there? Wasn’t Maasik on her way home to be milked?”

“I didn’t drive her anywhere,” the boy cried. “She just went there all by herself. She didn’t want to fall behind the others.”

“There’s some new grass on the hummocks in the marsh. That’s why,” Mari, the cottager, explained. “The upland meadow is bare. The animals can’t get hold of anything with their teeth. They can only lick the ground with their tongues. Animals aren’t stupid— they know where to go.”

“But what now?” the mistress asked, at a loss.

“We have to go help her. What else?” Madis, the other cottager, replied. Turning to the boy, he asked, “Where is she? Somewhere in the big marsh?”

“No, in the small one,” Eedi answered. “She got through the big one, leaving a trail behind her. She was belly-deep, but she kept on going, mooing once in a while.”

“Well, I’ll be damned,” cursed Madis. “To get through the big one and then get stuck in the smaller!” He added, “But if it’s the small marsh, that’s not so bad. We can get her out by ourselves.”

Quickly they emptied the wagon and loaded it with planks and ropes. When the men and the boy climbed on, the mistress tried to join them, but Madis stopped her.

“No, Mistress. Pulling a cow out of the marsh isn’t women’s work.” Turning to the others, he added, “We better take flint and steel and some straw in case we need to build a fire to warm her. The marsh is still cold and that stiffens an animal’s legs. Not long ago the ground was frozen hard.”

The wagon started moving.

Biosemiotician Kalevi Kull has pointed out that in addition to humans, the land of Estonia is home for more than 30,000 species of living creatures - birds and animals, fish and amphibians, vascular plants and mosses, algae, insects etc. Estonia looks the way we know it exactly because all these species cohabit this land and their wellbeing in this environment is mutually interrelated. We might ask, though, why is it important to recognize and one's colanders and know which ways of life and which habitats suit them? The answer is - in order to preserve our home and in order to be able to resolve conflicts that potentially take place between different species.  

infoVaata seda lehte tahvlis või lauaarvutis, siis saad lahendada ka põnevaid ülesandeid.
  • Part I
  • Part II
  • Part III

Part 1

Form groups of 5-6 people. Each group has to search the (digital version of the) novel “Truth and Justice” for mentionings of a given animal: a pig, a horse, a cow, a dog and a cat. One of the groups can look for the mentionings of all other species than the aforementioned (such as birds, snakes etc.). While searching, keep in mind that sometimes the animals were mentioned by name (Pollo, Maasik etc.).

  1. In which situations the animal was mentioned? Which words (adjectives, verbs etc.) were used to describe it? What can we infer from these scenes about the relations between man and the given species at the time?
  2. Next, find a contemporary YouTube video or an image that mediates the relation between man and the same species today. Watch the videos in class and discuss what has changed in the relationships.
  3. Discuss and present the representation of the animal to the other groups. Have you ever judged people by their relationship with animals?

Part 2

The relationships between humans and other species inhabiting Estonia have changed a lot since the end of the 19th century.

The species we are able to recognize and designate, use for food or for assistance, or just value as companions, and where such actions take place, would probably surprise the people of Tammsaare's Vargamäe. For example, zoosemiotician Nelly Mäekivi has described how our understanding of which species are worthy of protection in nature depends much more on human values and the meanings created in culture, than on the actual needs of the natural environment. Thomas Sebeok, the founder of zoosemiotics, has proposed a typology of eight relations that one could distinguish between men and other animals. It is important to note that all of these relations have both a biological and a cultural dimension. 

  1. The human being as a predator of other animals, and vice versa
  2. The human being as a partner of other animals
  3. The human being as an exploiter of other animals in sports and hobbies
  4. The human being as a parasite of other animals, and vice versa
  5. The non-human animal establishing relations of conspecificity with the human being (for instance, when a dog treats her owner as a member of a pack). 
  6. The non-human animal establishing relations of insensibility with the human being, and vice versa
  7. The human being domesticating other animals
  8. The human being training other animals, and vice versa (for instance, an owner is accustomed to walk her dog exactly at the moment when the dog brings a leash)

Task

  • Try to find examples of each relationship from the Truth and Justice novel or film. If you do not find examples from these sources, try to find an example — an image, video, or verbal text — from the Internet.
  • Which of these types of relations were most prevalent at the time of Truth and Justice, and which dominate today? Could you add anything to this typology?

Part 3

Jakob von Uexküll, a Baltic German biologist, proposed the term "Umwelt" for describing the subjective world of animals, which is based on their species-specific senses and the way of life in a specific environment. These senses determine what the animal is capable of perceiving in its environment. Information about changes in the surrounding environment reaches the animal through its receptors in the form of a perceptual cue-bearer, which functions as a sign. In effect, the stimulation, which is received and translated into a sign, will initiate a response process, e.g. movement away from or towards a sound, a smell, etc. This kind of chain or feedback loop between stimulus and sign response was described by Uexküll as a functional cycle, which we may regard as a model of the Umwelt.

Task

Let us look at the Umwelt of some species portrayed in Truth and Justice more closely.

  1. Listen to zoosemiotician Nelly Mäekivi descriptions of the senses of seeing and hearing of horses, cows, dogs, and pigs.
  2. Choose a scene from the novel in which the given species is present. Keeping in mind the information about their senses, create a script and based on this a video or digital storytelling project mediating the scene from the perspective (the point of view and hearing) of the chosen animal. There are a number of different applications for editing videos, such as: Filmora, Videorama, Quick, and iMovie.

Pig

Cow

Dog

Horse

home i
add remove